Hip Arthroscopy for FAIS: Long-Term Football Outcomes

Key Takeaways
- Among high school and collegiate American football athletes after arthroscopy for symptomatic femoroacetabular impingement syndrome (FAIS), the paper’s detailed results report that 21 of 35 respondents (60%) returned to preinjury football, and 21 of 23 who attempted to return (91%) succeeded.
- At a mean 6.3-year follow-up, 69%, 77%, and 80% met patient acceptable symptom state thresholds on the mHHS, iHOT-12, and HOS-Sport, respectively.
- Greater preoperative alpha angle was significantly associated with poorer scores on all three scales; older age at surgery was significantly associated with a poorer iHOT-12 score and lower odds of returning.
For the hip arthroscopy outcomes study in Archives of Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery, the investigators retrospectively identified skeletally mature, competitively playing high school and collegiate athletes treated at Andrews Sports Medicine and Orthopaedic Center in Birmingham, Alabama, during 2013–2020. Athletes underwent arthroscopic femoroplasty and/or acetabuloplasty, with labral treatment as indicated, and had at least two years of follow-up. Of 56 eligible athletes, three later ipsilateral hip procedures counted as endpoints and were excluded from patient-reported outcome (PRO) collection; 35 of the remaining 53 completed postoperative hip-score, patient acceptable symptom state (PASS), and return-to-preinjury-football questionnaires by telephone or secure link. All respondents were male. Investigators compared blocking-position and capsule-closure groups and assessed age and radiographic measures using univariable regressions.
Mean postoperative scores were 82.2 on the modified Harris Hip Score (mHHS), 84.6 on the International Hip Outcome Tool-12 (iHOT-12), and 88.3 on the Hip Outcome Score Sport Specific Subscale (HOS-Sport). PASS attainment describes postoperative symptom status, not improvement from baseline. Greater preoperative alpha angle was significantly associated with poorer scores on all three instruments; older surgical age was significantly associated with a poorer iHOT-12 score and lower odds of returning. Blocking-position and capsular-closure comparisons, and tested associations with follow-up duration and lateral center-edge angle, were not significant.
Overall, 21 of 35 respondents returned to preinjury football; 23 of 35 attempted to return, 21 of whom succeeded, while 12 of 35 did not attempt it. Athletes whose attempted returns failed reported hip pain or reduced hip-related sports performance. Return among attempters does not describe return among all respondents.
Among athletes eligible for questionnaires, 18 of 53 did not provide PRO data, leaving a small, all-male respondent group from one center. Without preoperative PROs, improvement and minimal clinically important differences could not be calculated; PASS reflects acceptable postoperative symptoms, not a treatment effect. Recall bias, limited power for position comparisons, and regression comparisons unadjusted for multiplicity further constrain interpretation.
The authors distinguished postoperative hip status from return to preinjury football, including return conditional on attempting to play again. They characterized the associations with surgical age and preoperative alpha angle as observational rather than causal.
Clinician Questions
Why did some high school and collegiate football players not return to preinjury football after FAIS arthroscopy?
Among high school and collegiate American football athletes treated arthroscopically for symptomatic FAIS, ten of 14 who did not return cited graduation or insufficient ability to advance to the next competitive level. Others cited personal reasons, while failed attempts involved hip symptoms or diminished hip-related sports performance. Reasons among all nonreturners should not be conflated with reasons for failed attempts.
How was preoperative alpha angle measured in football players undergoing hip arthroscopy for FAIS?
Investigators measured preoperative alpha angle on anteroposterior pelvic radiographs because Dunn views were not available for every athlete. The authors noted that the anteroposterior view may miss the greatest cam deformity, qualifying interpretation of the observed association.
What later ipsilateral hip procedures occurred among football players after arthroscopy for FAIS?
Among eligible high school and collegiate American football athletes treated arthroscopically for symptomatic FAIS, later ipsilateral procedures comprised two labral repairs and one total hip arthroplasty. Investigators counted these as endpoints and did not collect postoperative hip questionnaire scores for those athletes.
This content is intended for healthcare professionals for educational purposes. The article and its image were developed with AI assistance and reviewed by members of the ReachMD team prior to publication. Please refer to the original source linked for the complete and most up-to-date information.