medicalxpress.com
Florida has enacted a law permitting cesarean sections in clinics, which could serve as a model for other states. While the law aims to improve maternity care access and reduce costs, it faces opposition due to safety concerns and the involvement of private equity-backed physician groups. The law permits 'advanced birth centers' where C-sections can be performed, contrasting traditional hospital settings with detailed safety protocols.
Florida leads with a new model for cesarean sections outside traditional hospital settings.
In response to declining numbers of labor and delivery units nationally, Florida has enacted a law that permits C-sections at clinics. This legislative change seeks to improve access to maternity care, especially in underserved regions.
"We could see more healthcare lobbying, and specifically around this issue in other parts of the country," said Alex Borsa, a researcher at Columbia University.
The law introduces the concept of 'advanced birth centers,' distinct from traditional hospital settings but equipped to handle C-sections. Proponents advocate that these centers can provide much-needed services where hospital options are limited.
Private equity's influence in healthcare policy raises questions about priorities and motivations.
The lobbying efforts by private equity-backed physician groups have been central to the law's passage. Such groups often seek to maximize profit margins, which can conflict with healthcare outcomes.
"In addition to Florida being the Wild West in a number of policy directions, it has one of the highest concentrations of private equity-backed healthcare operators," Borsa observed.
The involvement of firms like Women's Care Enterprises raises concerns regarding the motivations behind healthcare models that prioritize fiscal efficiency over comprehensive patient care.
Adequate safety protocols are essential when implementing new healthcare models.
Medical professionals have voiced concerns that advanced birth centers may not replicate hospital conditions effectively enough to ensure patient safety during C-sections. The potential lack of immediate access to multidisciplinary teams and emergency equipment heightens safety risks.
"Both mom and baby deserve access to the best possible care," stated Mary Mayhew, President of the Florida Hospital Association.
This perspective underscores the critical need for hospital-level resources during surgical births, where complications may arise unexpectedly requiring prompt intervention.
Florida's policy may inspire similar initiatives, but each must consider local healthcare contexts.
The legislation could serve as a template for states looking to address local maternity care deficits. However, the differences in healthcare infrastructure and resource distribution necessitate a tailored approach to any implementation.
"What we're particularly hearing from are patients... who want options," commented state Sen. Colleen Burton.
This sentiment highlights a drive towards expanding patient choices, although ensuring these options maintain high standards of care remains pivotal to any successful rollout.
Vollers, A. C. (2025, February 3). New Florida law allowing C-sections outside hospitals could be national model. Medical Xpress. Retrieved February 3, 2025, from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2025-02-florida-law-sections-hospitals-national.html
Vollers, A. C. (2024, May 30). Florida allows doctors to perform C-sections outside of hospitals. Medical Xpress. Retrieved February 3, 2025, from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2024-05-florida-doctors-sections-hospitals.html
Vollers, A. C. (2025, January 29). Study finds better nurse staffing lowers C-section rates. Medical Xpress. Retrieved February 3, 2025, from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2025-01-nurse-staffing-lowers-section.html